What is the success rate of It's Just Lunch?
By Daniel Gourley — founder of The Wingmen, lifelong Phoenix native.
It's Just Lunch does not publish verified success rate data, and no independent study has established a reliable figure — any percentage you see cited online comes from the company's own marketing, not from audited outcomes. What they do track and promote is match volume and client satisfaction surveys, which is a very different thing from "led to a lasting relationship." If you're trying to decide whether to spend the money, that distinction matters a lot.
Why can't anyone give you a real number?
"Success" is undefined in the matchmaking industry. Does it mean a second date? A relationship at six months? A marriage? Every service gets to set its own goalposts, and none of them are required to report outcomes to a third party. It's Just Lunch has faced FTC complaints and class-action suits over the years related to service delivery and refund disputes — that's public record — which is worth knowing when you're evaluating marketing claims. The absence of a verifiable number isn't unique to them; it's industry-wide. Anyone quoting you a specific percentage without citing an independent source is repeating ad copy.
How does It's Just Lunch compare to the realistic alternatives?
Here's the honest comparison a Phoenix man in his 40s or 50s actually needs to make:
| Option | Crowd in Phoenix | Upfront Cost | Effort Required | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| It's Just Lunch | Professionals, 30s–50s, variable depth of vetting | $1,500–$3,000+ (widely reported range; verify current pricing) | Low — they set the dates | Busy guys who want zero logistics and can absorb the cost without stress |
| Local independent matchmakers | Smaller pool, often more carefully curated | $3,000–$25,000+ depending on tier | Low-to-medium | Men who want genuine human judgment and a dedicated advocate |
| Hinge / Bumble | Large, broad age range, highly variable quality | Free to ~$35/month | High — you run everything | Men who like control, have time, and are good in writing |
| Upscale singles events (Phoenix) | Mixed, 30s–60s, social-first | $30–$150/event | Medium — show up, be present | Men who want to practice being in the room before committing to a date |
| A curated social club | Vetted, interest-aligned, recurring relationships | Membership varies | Medium — consistent participation | Men who want organic connection over time, not a transactional date |
Cost ranges above are based on widely reported consumer estimates and vary by market and package — always get the current quote in writing before signing.
Which one, when?
You're slammed at work and hate the app game. It's Just Lunch or an independent matchmaker makes sense. You're paying for logistics and access, not magic. Go in clear-eyed: you're buying introductions, not outcomes.
You want the most vetted experience and have the budget. A boutique local matchmaker typically spends more time on your file and has stronger accountability because they live and work in your city. Ask them how they vet women, how many active women are in their Phoenix pool right now, and what happens if you're unhappy after five matches.
You're recently out of a long marriage and rusty. Don't start with the most expensive service. Go to a few events first. Get comfortable being in a room with new people before you pay someone to put you across a lunch table from a stranger.
You want volume and speed. Apps win on raw numbers. The effort is real, but so is the access.
You want something to grow into. A recurring social community — where you see some of the same faces, build actual rapport over months, and meet people through people — tends to produce the relationships men in their 40s and 50s describe as their best ones. It's slower. It's also more honest.
What's the best pick for a typical guy reading this?
For most men in the Phoenix rebuild — mid-career, not a lot of free time, skeptical of apps, willing to invest but not throw money at a black box — the answer is usually: start with low-stakes social exposure, then layer in a service if you still want the structure. Paying $2,000+ before you've shaken the rust off is often wasted money, because your first few dates after a long marriage are going to be awkward regardless of how good the match is on paper.
It's Just Lunch is not a scam. It is also not magic, and their unverifiable success rate number should not be the reason you sign. The reason to sign — or not — is whether you've talked to recent clients, read the contract carefully, and decided the logistics value is worth the price at this point in your life.
In Phoenix? Apply for an invite to The Wingmen — vetted members, the city's best rooms, honest coaching.
Anywhere else (or just looking)? See this week's Phoenix singles events — the public slate, updated weekly.
The Wingmen is our club — invite-only, Phoenix. We wrote this guide.
Browse the full Field Guide · The Wingmen — invite-only, Phoenix